HSK 7
哪有X这么Y的/有X这样Y的吗
nǎ yǒu X zhè me Y de / yǒu X zhè yàng Y de ma
Rebuttal or surprise sentence structure: 哪有X这么Y的 / 有X这样Y的吗
Explanation
These are two colloquial constructions (口语格式, templates used in speech) in the form of rhetorical questions used to rebut, criticize, or express surprise at someone X's behavior/character Y: "哪有X这么Y的" and "有X这样Y的吗".
(1) 哪有 (nǎ yǒu) + X (person) + 这么/那么 (zhème / nàme) + Y (quality/behavior) + 的 (de) ? ; (2) 有 (yǒu) + X + 这样 (zhèyàng) + Y + 的吗 (de ma) ? The character "哪" (nǎ) and the interrogative structure here actually affirm the negative sense "there's no such thing as", "nobody acts like that".
in conversation, when annoyed, reproachful, or astonished to see someone behaving outrageously or unlike anyone else.
"哪有X这么Y的" emphasizes denial and criticism ("how can there be such a…"); "有X这样Y的吗" is a rhetorical question emphasizing disbelief and indignation ("is there anyone who would… like that"). Both are rhetorical questions requiring no answer.
mistaking these for genuine questions (these are rhetorical questions implying negation/reproach); omitting the character "的" at the end, which breaks the construction; using them in formal contexts (this is emotionally charged colloquial speech).
Examples
How can anyone be as outrageous as you? You've grabbed all the benefits for yourself.
How can anyone be as blunt as you? Leave the person a bit of face.
Is there anyone who conducts themselves like him? Always badmouthing others behind their backs.
Practice
Test your understanding with a quick quiz
Learn “哪有X这么Y的/有X这样Y的吗” effectively
The grammar point “哪有X这么Y的/有X这样Y的吗” (Rebuttal or surprise sentence structure: 哪有X这么Y的 / 有X这样Y的吗) is one of the key structures at HSK 7. To use it fluently, you need to understand the contexts where it's used and practice regularly.
Study tip: read the examples aloud many times to build a natural reflex. Then try making your own sentences for your own situations. Use the audio button to hear and practice accurate pronunciation.
You can also view the full “” lesson to understand the related grammar and vocabulary more deeply.